3 {SELECT * FROM t1 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t2 ON (45)}
} {
  do_catchsql_test e_select-1.12.$tn "
    $sql
  " {1 {a NATURAL join may not have an ON or USING clause}}
}












































































































































































































































finish_test

  3 {SELECT * FROM t1 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t2 ON (45)}
} {
  do_catchsql_test e_select-1.12.$tn "
    $sql
  " {1 {a NATURAL join may not have an ON or USING clause}}
}


#-------
# Usage:   tcl_join <table-data1> <table-data2> <join spec>...
#
# Where a join-spec is an optional list of arguments as follows:
#
#   ?-left? 
#   ?-using colname-list using-expr-proc?
#   ?-on on-expr-proc?
#
proc tcl_join {data1 data2 args} {

  set testproc ""
  set usinglist [list]
  set isleft 0
  for {set i 0} {$i < [llength $args]} {incr i} {
    set a [lindex $args $i]
    switch -- $a {
      -on { set testproc [lindex $args [incr i]] }
      -using { 
        set usinglist [lindex $args [incr i]]
      }
      -left {
        set isleft 1
      }

      default {
        error "Unknown argument: $a"
      }
    }
  }

  set c1 [lindex $data1 0]
  set c2 [lindex $data2 0]
  set omitlist [list]
  set nullrowlist [list]
  set cret $c1

  set cidx 0
  foreach col $c2 {
    set idx [lsearch $usinglist $col]
    if {$idx>=0} {lappend omitlist $cidx}
    if {$idx<0} {
      lappend nullrowlist {NULL {}}
      lappend cret $col
    }
    incr cidx
  }
  set omitlist [lsort -integer -decreasing $omitlist]


  set rret [list]
  foreach r1 [lindex $data1 1] {
    set one 0
    foreach r2 [lindex $data2 1] {
      set ok 1
      if {$testproc != ""} {
        set ok [eval $testproc [list $c1 $r1 $c2 $r2]]
      }
      if {$ok} {
        set one 1
        foreach idx $omitlist {set r2 [lreplace $r2 $idx $idx]}
        lappend rret [concat $r1 $r2]
      }
    }

    if {$isleft && $one==0} {
      lappend rret [concat $r1 $nullrowlist]
    }
  }
  
  list $cret $rret
}

proc tcl_tbljoin {db t1 t2 args} {
  tcl_join [tcl_read_tbl $db $t1] [tcl_read_tbl $db $t2] {*}$args
}

#----------
# te_equals ?SWITCHES? c1 c2 cols1 row1 cols2 row2
#
proc te_equals {args} {

  if {[llength $args]<6} {error "invalid arguments to te_equals"}
  foreach {c1 c2 cols1 row1 cols2 row2} [lrange $args end-5 end] break

  set nocase 0

  foreach a [lrange $args 0 end-6] {
    switch -- $a {
      -nocase {
        set nocase 1
      }
      default {
        error "invalid arguments to te_equals"
      }
    }
  }

  set idx1 [lsearch $cols1 $c1]
  set idx2 [lsearch $cols2 $c2]

  set t1 [lindex $row1 $idx1 0]
  set t2 [lindex $row2 $idx2 0]
  set v1 [lindex $row1 $idx1 1]
  set v2 [lindex $row2 $idx2 1]

  if {$t1 == "NULL" || $t2 == "NULL"} { return 0 }
  if {$nocase && $t1 == "TEXT"} { set v1 [string tolower $v1] }
  if {$nocase && $t2 == "TEXT"} { set v2 [string tolower $v2] }
  return [expr {$t1 == $t2 && $v1 == $v2}]
}

proc te_and {args} {
  foreach a [lrange $args 0 end-4] {
    set res [eval $a [lrange $args end-3 end]]
    if {$res == 0} {return 0}
  }
  return 1
}

# Read the
#
# Table data format:
#
#   * List of column names.
#
#   * List of rows. Each row is a list of values. Each value is a list of
#     2 elements - the value type and string representation.
#
proc tcl_read_tbl {db tbl} { tcl_read_sql $db "SELECT * FROM $tbl" }

proc tcl_read_sql {db sql} {
  set S [sqlite3_prepare_v2 $db $sql -1 DUMMY]

  set cols [list]
  for {set i 0} {$i < [sqlite3_column_count $S]} {incr i} {
    lappend cols [sqlite3_column_name $S $i]
  }

  set rows [list]
  while {[sqlite3_step $S] == "SQLITE_ROW"} {
    set r [list]
    for {set i 0} {$i < [sqlite3_column_count $S]} {incr i} {
      lappend r [list [sqlite3_column_type $S $i] [sqlite3_column_text $S $i]]
    }
    lappend rows $r
  }
  sqlite3_finalize $S

  return [list $cols $rows]
}

drop_all_tables
do_execsql_test e_select-2.0 {
  CREATE TABLE t1(a, b);
  CREATE TABLE t2(a, b);
  CREATE TABLE t3(b COLLATE nocase);

  INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(1, 'A');
  INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(2, 'B');
  INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(3, NULL);
  INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(4, 'D');
  INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(NULL, NULL);

  INSERT INTO t2 VALUES(1, 'A');
  INSERT INTO t2 VALUES(2, NULL);
  INSERT INTO t2 VALUES(3, 'C');
  INSERT INTO t2 VALUES(5, 'E');
  INSERT INTO t2 VALUES(NULL, NULL);

  INSERT INTO t3 VALUES('a');
  INSERT INTO t3 VALUES('b');
  INSERT INTO t3 VALUES('c');
} {}

foreach {tn sqljoin tbljoinargs} {
  1     "t1, t2"                         {t1 t2}
  2     "t1, t2 ON (t1.a=t2.a)"          {t1 t2 -on {te_equals a a}}
  3     "t1 LEFT JOIN t2 ON (t1.a=t2.a)" {t1 t2 -left -on {te_equals a a}}
  4     "t1 LEFT JOIN t2 USING (a)"      
          {t1 t2 -left -using a -on {te_equals a a}}

  5     "t1 CROSS JOIN t2 USING(b, a)" 
        {t1 t2 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}

  6     "t1 NATURAL JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  7     "t1 NATURAL INNER JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  8     "t1 NATURAL CROSS JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  9     "t1 NATURAL INNER JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  10    "t1 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -left -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  11    "t1 NATURAL LEFT OUTER JOIN t2" 
        {t1 t2 -left -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}

  12    "t2 NATURAL JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  13    "t2 NATURAL INNER JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  14    "t2 NATURAL CROSS JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  15    "t2 NATURAL INNER JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  16    "t2 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -left -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}
  17    "t2 NATURAL LEFT OUTER JOIN t1" 
        {t2 t1 -left -using {a b} -on {te_and {te_equals a a} {te_equals b b}}}

  18    "t1 LEFT JOIN t2 USING (b)"      
        {t1 t2 -left -using b -on {te_equals b b}}

  19    "t1 JOIN t3 USING(b)" {t1 t3 -using b -on {te_equals b b}}
  20    "t3 JOIN t1 USING(b)" {t3 t1 -using b -on {te_equals -nocase b b}}
  21    "t1 NATURAL JOIN t3"  {t1 t3 -using b -on {te_equals b b}}
  22    "t3 NATURAL JOIN t1"  {t3 t1 -using b -on {te_equals -nocase b b}}
  23    "t1 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t3"  {t1 t3 -left -using b -on {te_equals b b}}
  24    "t3 NATURAL LEFT JOIN t1"  
        {t3 t1 -left -using b -on {te_equals -nocase b b}}

  25    "t1 LEFT JOIN t3 ON (t3.b=t1.b)" 
        {t1 t3 -left -on {te_equals -nocase b b}}
  26    "t1 LEFT JOIN t3 ON (t1.b=t3.b)"  
        {t1 t3 -left -on {te_equals b b}}

} {

  do_test e_select-2.1.$tn [list tcl_read_sql db "SELECT * FROM $sqljoin"
  ] [tcl_tbljoin db {*}$tbljoinargs]

}

finish_test